It’s Not Just Harry Connick Jr.: Paper Mill Announces Full Cast for The Sting

Kate Shindle, former Miss America, in "Fun Home"

Paper Mill Playhouse created a stir when it announced that Harry Connick Jr. would be starring in the musical production The Sting,—  based on the 1973 film starring Paul Newman and Robert Redford — this spring.

The show, with book by Bob Martin, music and lyrics by Mark Hollmann & Greg Kotis with Harry Connick, Jr., has its eyes on a Broadway run.

Now Paper Mill has announced the full cast for the show which includes the music by Scott Joplin including “The Entertainer.” (John Rando is set to direct with choreography by Warren Carlyle and music direction by Fred Lassen.)

The Sting begins performances on Thursday, March 29, 2018, for a limited engagement through Sunday, April 29, 2018, at Paper Mill Playhouse (22 Brookside Drive) in Millburn, NJ.  Opening Night is Sunday, April 8, 2018, at 7:00 p.m. Buy tickets here. 

The principal cast will star Harry Connick, Jr. as Henry Gondorff, with Peter Benson as The Erie Kid, Janet Dacal as Loretta, Christopher Gurr asJ.J. Singleton, J. Harrison Ghee as Johnny Hooker, Tom Hewitt as Doyle Lonnegan, Richard Kline as Kid Twist, Kevyn Morrow as Luther, Kate Shindle as Billie, and Robert Wuhl as Snyder.

Rounding out the cast are Lucien Barbarin, Darius Barnes, Keely Beirne, Michael Fatica, Luke Hawkins, Tyler Huckstep, Matt Loehr, Erica Mansfield, Drew McVety, Ramone Owens, Tyler Roberts, Angie Schworer, Christine Shepard, Britton Smith, Sherisse Springer, Diana Vaden, Kevin Worley and Lara Seibert Young.

The Sting will be performed eight times a week, Wednesday through SundayThe performance schedule is Wednesday at 7:30 p.m., Thursday at1:30 p.m. & 7:30 p.m.Friday at 8:00 p.m.Saturday at 1:30 p.m. & 8:00 p.m. and Sunday at 1:30 p.m. & 7:00 p.m.

Tickets are on sale now starting at $34. Tickets may be purchased by calling 973.376.4343, at the Paper Mill Playhouse Box Office at 22 Brookside Drive in Millburn, or online at Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express accepted. Groups of 10 or more can receive up to a 40% discount on tickets and should call 973.315.1680. Students may order $23 rush tickets over the phone or in person at the Paper Mill Playhouse box office on the day of the performance. Paper Mill Playhouse’s 2017/2018 season is proudly sponsored by Investors Bank.

The production team includes set design by Beowulf Boritt, costume design by Paul Tazewell, lighting design by Japhy Weideman, sound design byRandy Hansen, hair and wig design by Charles G. LaPointe, make up design by Cookie Jordan, vocal arrangements by Fred Lassen, dance arrangements by David Chase, orchestrations by Doug Besterman, and fight coordinator Robert Westley. The production stage manager is Bonnie L. Becker. Casting is by Tara Rubin Casting, Tara Rubin, CSA.

“At J.P. Morgan we see the arts as valuable expressions of creative ideas, that have a real and lasting benefit to society,” said Deborah Kennedy, Managing Director, J.P. Morgan Private Bank. “We wish the cast, crew and all involved in the production of The Sting a fantastic first night and a wonderful run. We are eager to see the culmination of their hard work and inventive energy.”

Harry Connick, Jr(Henry Gondorff/Music and Lyrics) a multiple Grammy and Emmy winner, began performing in his native New Orleans at age five. He has released 30 albums, highlighting his talents as pianist, singer, songwriter, composer, and orchestrator, garnering over 28 million sales. Connick received Tony nominations for his performance as Sid Sorokin in The Pajama Game and for his score to Thou Shalt Not (directed by Susan Stroman). He last performed on Broadway in On a Clear Day You Can See Forever, following the 2010 run of Harry Connick, Jr. in Concert on Broadway, which marked the 20th anniversary of his first sold-out concert series on Broadway. He has appeared in 19 films including Dolphin Tale with Morgan Freeman, Hope Floatswith Sandra Bullock, P.S. I Love You with Hilary Swank, Bug with Ashley Judd, and Copycat with Sigourney Weaver, and on television (American IdolWill & GraceSouth Pacific). In the fall of 2016, he launched Harry, a nationally syndicated daytime television show featuring his touring band, which earned five Daytime Emmy nominations in its first season, including best host, and a Critics’ Choice nomination for best talk show. Connick received the Jefferson Award for Public Service in recognition of his efforts to help New Orleans rebuild after the devastation of Hurricane Katrina. 

Peter Benson (The Erie Kid). On Broadway, Mr. Benson has appeared in The Mystery of Edwin DroodHarveyPromises, PromisesTo Be or Not to Be;Boeing-BoeingThe Pajama Game (with Harry Connick, Jr.—Outer Critics Circle nomination); Wonderful TownCabaretLittle MeAn American Daughter; and State Fair. He has appeared Off Broadway in Distracted (Roundabout), Birth and After Birth (Atlantic), The New Moon (City Center Encores!), The Country Club (Drama Dept.), Maddening Truth (Keen), Urban Dictionary Plays (twice at Ars Nova), and many others. Recent television guest stars includeLouieHorace and PeteBanshee (season 4), ElementaryThe AmericansBlue Bloods, and Blacklist.

Janet Dacal (Loretta) makes her Paper Mill Playhouse debut in The Sting. She most recently starred in Hal Prince’s Prince of Broadway, playing multiple roles including Evita, Aurora in Kiss of the Spider Woman, and Sydney in It’s a Bird…It’s a Plane…. She created the role of Alice in Frank Wildhorn’sWonderland. She played the lead, Nina Rosario, in In the Heights after originating the role of Carla in the Off Broadway and Broadway productions, for which she received a Drama Desk Award. Additional favorite roles include Rosie in Bye Bye Birdie, Kathy in The Last Five Years, and Maria Merelli in Lend Me a Tenor.

 Harrison Ghee(Johnny Hooker)is honored to be creating the role of Johnny Hooker in The Sting and to make his Paper Mill Playhouse debut. Broadway/International Tour: Kinky Boots (Lola/swing). Regional: The Color Purple (ensemble). Television: High Maintenance (“Globo,” Charles). Industrial: Tokyo DisneySea’s Big Band Beat, Norwegian Cruise Line. Proud graduate of AMDA (NY).

Christopher Gurr (J.J. Singleton) recently starred as Gus in the Trevor Nunn/Andy Blankenbuehler Broadway revival of Cats. Other Broadway credits:Tuck EverlastingKinky BootsAmazing Grace, and All the Way with Bryan Cranston. First National Tours: MemphisSpamalot. Regional: Copenhagen,1776Twelve Angry MenMy Fair Lady (Geva); The Who’s TommyOklahoma! (Berkshire Theatre Festival); Getting the Band Back Together (George Street); The Lion in Winter (Indiana Rep); The Drowsy Chaperone (Human Race). TV: Madame Secretary. Thanks to

Tom Hewitt (Doyle Lonnegan). Paper Mill: Jane EyreMan of La Mancha. Broadway includes: Amazing GraceDoctor ZhivagoJesus Christ Superstar,ChicagoDraculaThe Boys from SyracuseThe Rocky Horror Show (Tony, Drama Desk nominations), The Lion KingSchool for ScandalThe SistersRosensweig. National Tours: Finding NeverlandUrinetownDirty Rotten ScoundrelsPeter Pan. Off Broadway: Another MedeaTreasure IslandJeffery,Beau Jest (Outer Critics nomination). Recent regional credits: My Paris (Long Wharf), Irma Vep (BTG), Spamalot (PCLO, TUTS, Starlight), Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots (La Jolla Playhouse), Travesties (Long Wharf—Connecticut Critics Circle Award). Film/TV: ElementaryLaw & Order, Julie Taymor’s Fool’s Fire.

Richard Kline (Kid Twist). Broadway: City of AngelsNovember. Regional: By JeevesMizlansky/ZilinskyAnd a Nightingale SangSpamalotSunshine BoysCompanyTitanicTroilus and CressidaHenry VChemin de FerDeath of a Salesman, and others, at such theaters as the Kennedy Center, Geffen Playhouse, Penguin Rep, Intiman Theatre, Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park, Westport Country Playhouse, Mint Theater, Goodspeed Opera, Folger Shakespeare Theatre. Tours: Wicked (The Wizard), Jake’s Women. Solo show: Boychik. Film: Don’t Think TwiceLiberty HeightsI Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry. TV: The AmericansBlue BloodsThree’s Company (Larry Dallas), and over 75 more including L.A. LawNYPD BlueSt. Elsewhere, andMaude.

Kevyn Morrow (Luther). Broadway: The Color Purple (revival), BandstandThe Scarlet PimpernelDreamSmokey Joes CafeA Chorus Line (1990 closing company), Dreamgirls (revival), Leader of the Pack. West End: Ragtime (Olivier nomination), 125th Street. Off Broadway: While I Yet LiveBoys in the BandBlue. Regional: First Wives Club (NAACP nomination), Driving Miss DaisyThe Lion in WinterRadio GolfGem of the OceanPajama GameThe Three MusketeersTambourine to Glory (Helen Hayes nomination). Film: Fair Market ValueThe TradeStayin’ Alive. Television: Recurring: The Path,ElementaryHope & FaithEd; Guest: Person of InterestGood WifeHostagesLaw & OrderCoachMurphy Brown.

Kate Shindle (Billie) recently wrapped up the acclaimed first national tour of Fun Home (Alison). Proud Jersey girl excited to make her Paper Mill debut. Broadway: Legally Blonde (Vivienne), Cabaret (Sally Bowles), Wonderland (Hatter), Jekyll & Hyde. Other favorites: After the Fall (Maggie); Rapture, Blister, Burn (Catherine); Gypsy (Louise); Into the Woods (Witch); Sympathy JonesThe Last Five YearsFirst Lady Suite. TV/Film: Lucky Stiff (Dominique), Law & Order: SVUWhite CollarGossip GirlThe Stepford Wives. Kate is currently president of both Actors’ Equity Association and Theatre Authority.

Robert Wuhl (Lt. Snyder) is a proud member of the Union (New Jersey) High School Hall of Fame. Movies: BatmanBull DurhamGood Morning, VietnamThe BodyguardFlashdanceMistressHollywood KnightsCobbGood BurgerOpen Season (also writer/director). He created and starred in the HBO series Arli$$ (CableACE nomination) and Assume the Position with Mr. Wuhl (Writers Guild Award nomination). Other TV: Tales from the Crypt(CableACE nomination), American DadBlue BloodsPolice Squad (writer), 60 Minutes Sports (contributor.) He received two Emmy Awards for writing the 63rd and 64th Academy Awards 

Bob Martin (Book) has been working as an actor and writer for over three decades. He has received many awards in both Canada and the US, including a Tony for The Drowsy Chaperone. Recent TV projects include Slings & Arrows, seasons 1, 2, and 3 (TMN, Sundance); Michael: Tuesdays and Thursdays(CBC); Michael: Every Day (CBC); Sensitive Skin, seasons 1 and 2 (HBO); and Elf: Buddy’s Musical Christmas (NBC). Recent theater projects include Encores! (NYC), The Prom (Atlanta), Gotta Dance (Chicago), Elf (Broadway, Dublin, London), The Drowsy Chaperone (Toronto, Broadway, London), Second City Toronto (performer, director, artistic director). In development: MillionsHalf TimeThe Princess Bride.

Mark Hollmann (Music & Lyrics) won the Tony Award, the National Broadway Theatre Award, and the Obie Award for his music and lyrics to Urinetown: The Musical. His other shows as composer/lyricist include Yeast Nation and Bigfoot and Other Lost Souls. He is a member of the American Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers (ASCAP), serves on the council of the Dramatists Guild of America, and has served on the Tony Nominating Committee.

Greg Kotis (Lyrics) is the author of many plays and musicals including Urinetown (book/lyrics, for which he won an Obie Award and two Tony Awards),LunchtimeGive the People What They WantMichael von Siebenburg Melts Through the FloorboardsYeast Nation (book/lyrics), The Truth About Santa,Pig FarmEat the Taste, and Jobey and Katherine. Future projects include ZM, a new musical that follows two teenage fast-food workers as they struggle to survive a foodborne zombie apocalypse. Greg is a member of ASCAP and the Dramatists Guild and is a cofounder of Theater of the Apes.

John Rando (Director). Select Broadway: On the Town (Tony nomination), Penn & Teller on BroadwayA Christmas StoryThe Wedding Singer, Urinetown(Tony, Outer Critics Circle Awards), A Thousand ClownsThe Dinner Party. Off Broadway: Jerry Springer: The OperaLives of the SaintsThe Heir Apparent(SDCF Callaway Award), All in the Timing (Obie Award), The Toxic Avenger, among others. Recent regional: The Honeymooners (Paper Mill), Pirates of Penzance (Barrington), Big Sky (Geffen Playhouse). City Center Encores!: The New YorkersAnnie Get Your GunLittle Me, It’s a Bird…It’s a Plane…,Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, On the Town, Damn Yankees, Strike Up the Band, The Pajama Game, Of Thee I Sing, and more. He also directed Carousel for the New York Philharmonic.


Warren Carlyle (Choreographer). Broadway: Directed and choreographed: After Midnight (Tony Award for Best Choreography), ChaplinHugh Jackman: Back on BroadwayFinian’s Rainbow (Tony nomination), A Tale of Two Cities. Choreography: Hello, Dolly!She Loves MeOn the Twentieth CenturyThe Mystery of Edwin DroodA Christmas StoryFollies. Directed and choreographed Radio City’s New York Spring Spectacular starring the Rockettes. TV/Film: Staged and choreographed the 68th and 69th Annual Tony Awards (CBS), multiple seasons of So You Think You Can Dance (Fox), Deception starring Hugh Jackman (20th Century Fox), Carousel (PBS) (Emmy nomination). Awards: Two Outer Critics Circle Awards, Drama Desk Award, Astaire Award.


Doug Besterman (Orchestrations). Three-time Tony Award winner. Broadway: Charlie and the Chocolate FactoryAnastasiaA Bronx TaleIt Shoulda Been YouBullets Over Broadway (Tony nomination), RockyOn a Clear Day…Sister ActHow to Succeed… (Tony nomination), ElfYoung Frankenstein(Drama Desk nomination), TarzanDraculaThoroughly Modern Millie (2002 Tony and Drama Desk Awards), The Producers (2001 Tony and Drama Desk Awards), SeussicalThe Music Man (Tony and Drama Desk nominations), Fosse (1999 Tony), Big (Drama Desk nomination), Damn Yankees (Drama Desk nomination). International: Guys and Dolls. Off Broadway: CarrieWeird Romance. Regional: Little DancerCalvin Berger. Film/Television: Beauty and the BeastPeter Pan Live!The Sound of Music Live!FrozenMulanChicago.


Fred Lassen (Music Director/Vocal Arrangements). Broadway: Prince of BroadwayBandstandFinding NeverlandOncePorgy and BessSouth Pacific,Dirty Rotten ScoundrelsSpamalotCabaret42nd Street. Paper Mill: Animal CrackersSouth PacificPeter Pan. Off Broadway/Regional: Threepenny Opera(Atlantic), Zorro (Alliance Theatre). Associate music supervisor for NBC’s live telecasts of The Sound of Music and Peter Pan. Helen Hayes Award nomination for outstanding musical direction of Ricky Ian Gordon’s Sycamore Trees (Signature, DC). International: 4 Stars (Tokyo/Osaka), Maury Yeston’sPeony Pavilion (Beijing), Cabaret (Folies Bergère, Paris). Arranged/produced Laura Osnes’s albums Dream a Little Dream: Live at the Café Carlyle and If I Tell You.

David Chase (Dance Arrangements) has been music directing, supervising, and arranging music on Broadway for over two decades. Currently running: dance music for CarouselFrozenAnastasia, and Hello, Dolly!. Also: many arrangements and orchestrations for the Boston Pops, Radio City, the Kennedy Center Honors, and TV’s Crazy Ex-Girlfriend. His choral arrangements are published by G. Schirmer. Two Emmy nominations for music direction and a Grammy nomination for producing.


Beowulf Boritt (Scenic Design). Paper Mill: The Honeymooners, A Bronx Tale. Broadway: Act One (Tony Award), The Scottsboro Boys (Tony nomination),Thérèse Raquin (Tony nomination), On the Town, ChaplinCome from AwayMeteor ShowerPrince of BroadwaySunday in the Park with George (2017),A Bronx TaleHand to GodSondheim on Sondheim…Spelling BeeLovemusikRock of AgesBronx BombersGraceThe Two and Only. Off Broadway: 100 shows including The Last Five YearsThe Toxic Avenger, and Miss Julie. Work ranges from NYC Ballet to the Ringling Bros. Circus and internationally in England, Russia, China, Australia, and Japan. He received the 2007 Obie Award for Sustained Excellence in Set Design.


Paul Tazewell (Costume Design) designed the original Broadway production of the Pulitzer Prize– and Tony Award–winning Hamilton. Other Broadway: In the HeightsThe Color PurpleDr. ZhivagoMemphisCaroline, or ChangeElaine Stritch at LibertyBring in ’da Noise, Bring in ’da Funk; Russell Simmons’Def Poetry JamLombardiMagic/Bird. Broadway revivals: Side ShowA Streetcar Named DesireJesus Christ SuperstarGuys and DollsA Raisin in the SunOn the Town. In 2016, Paul received a Tony Award for Hamilton and an Emmy Award for The Wiz Live! on NBC. He also designed The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks starring Oprah Winfrey for HBO Films and Jesus Christ Superstar Live! for NBC.


Japhy Weideman (Lighting Design). Broadway: Dear Evan HansenThe VisitThe NanceOf Mice and MenAirline Highway, all Tony-nominated for best lighting design. Other Broadway: Charlie and the Chocolate FactoryLobby HeroBright StarSylviaOld TimesThe Heidi ChroniclesMacbeth (Drama Desk nomination), Cyrano de BergeracThe Snow Geese. Off Broadway: Lincoln Center Theater, Public Theater, NYTW, Second Stage, Playwrights Horizons, MTC, MCC, Labyrinth, Vineyard. West End: A Nice FishBlackbird. Opera: Bluebeard’s Castle/Il prigioniero (La Scala, Dutch National Opera); The (R)evolution of Steve JobsDon GiovanniLife Is a Dream (Santa Fe Opera); The Manchurian CandidateDoubt (Minnesota Opera); Don Giovanni (Lyon Opera).


Randy Hansen (Sound Design). Randy has designed sound for more than 150 musicals and 50 plays. Many memorable moments include working with the opera star Jessye Norman, the Indianapolis and Baltimore Symphony Orchestras, and the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. Having recently opened a national tour of The Little Mermaid, Randy is thrilled to be back at Paper Mill for The Sting. In New York City he was the president of Audible Difference, Inc., a sound design company that over the past 30 years has served the fashion industry in New York and Paris.


Charles G. Lapointe (Hair & Wig Design). Prior Paper Mill Playhouse productions include NewsiesThe Hunchback of Notre DameThe Outsider, and1776. Over 90 Broadway shows including HamiltonBeautiful: The Carole King MusicalAnastasiaThe Band’s VisitSpongeBob SquarePantsAmélie,MotownMemphisAllegianceA Gentleman’s Guide to Love & MurderThe Color PurpleDoctor ZhivagoOf Mice and MenVioletSide ShowThe Elephant ManAfter MidnightClybourne ParkNewsiesJekyll & HydeThe MountaintopSuperior DonutsBonnie and Clyde, and In the Heights. Television: The Wiz Live! (Emmy Award nomination), Blue BloodsAmerican CrimeMadoffHairspray.

Cookie Jordan (Makeup Design). Paper Mill: Lend Me a Tenor. Broadway: Once on This IslandSunday in the Park…In TransitEclipsedSide Show,After MidnightFela!A View from the BridgeSouth Pacific, others. Off Broadway: Jesus Hopped the A TrainIn the BloodThe Death of the Last Black Man… (Signature); Is God Is (Soho Rep); Kid Victory (Vineyard); A Midsummer Night’s DreamTroilus and CressidaParty PeopleThe Total Bent (Public);He Brought Her Heart Back in a BoxMeasure for Measure (TFANA). National Tours: Fela! (also Europe), Dirty DancingFlashdance. Regional: Hartford Stage, A.R.T., La Jolla, Goodspeed, Dallas Theater Center, McCarter, Berkeley Rep, Goodman. Emmy nomination for NBC’s The Wiz Live!.

Robert Westley (Fight Coordinator) choreographs movement for award-winning theater productions, acclaimed operas, and film, developing unique and exciting performances of dance, clowning, aerial acrobatics, puppetry, and martial art. Broadway: A Bronx Tale: The Musical (dir. Robert De Niro and Jerry Zaks), Hand to God. Off Broadway: Important Hats of the Twentieth Century (MTC), Verité (LCT3), Teenage Dick (Public). Paper Mill: The Honeymooners,A Bronx Tale.


Bonnie L. Becker (Production Stage Manager). Broadway: School of RockOn the TownThe Velocity of AutumnLet It BeNice Work If You Can Get It,Billy ElliotLegally BlondeLestatThe Glass MenagerieBombay DreamsThoroughly Modern MillieThe Real ThingThe Scarlet PimpernelVictor/Victoria,The Best Little Whorehouse Goes Public, and Jelly’s Last Jam. At Paper Mill Playhouse: West Side StoryRumorsRed, Hot and Blue.


Tara Rubin Casting (Casting). Previous Paper Mill: BandstandA Bronx TaleThe Hunchback of Notre DameCan-CanLes Misérables 25th Anniversary Tour. Selected Broadway: King Kong (upcoming), Summer (upcoming), Prince of BroadwayIndecentBandstandSunset BoulevardMiss SaigonDear Evan HansenA Bronx TaleCatsFalsettosDisaster!School of RockLes MisérablesThe HeiressThe Phantom of the OperaBilly ElliotShrekSpamalot,…Spelling BeeThe ProducersMamma Mia!Jersey Boys. Off Broadway: Jersey BoysHere Lies LoveOld Jews Telling JokesLove, Loss, and What I Wore. Regional: Berkeley Repertory Theatre, Yale Repertory Theatre, La Jolla Playhouse, Old Globe, Asolo Rep.

Accessibility Performances for The Sting

Paper Mill Playhouse, a leader in accessibility, will offer audio-described performances for The Sting on Sunday, April 22, at 1:30pm and Saturday, April 28, at 1:30pm. Prior to these performances at noon, the theater will offer free sensory seminars. Sensory seminars offer an opportunity for patrons with vision loss to hear a live, in-depth description of the production elements of the show and hands-on interaction with key sets, props, and costumes.  There will be a sign-interpreted and open-captioned performance on Sunday, April 29, at 7:00pm.


Free Audience Enrichment Activities for The Sting


Conversation Club: Join us Thursday evenings, March 29, April 5, 12 or 19, one hour before curtain for an informal, informative gathering. You’ll learn more about the performance you’re about to see.


The Director’s Viewpoint: One hour before curtain at 6:00pm on Wednesday, April 4, we host a pre-show discussion in the Renee Foosaner Art Gallery.


Q&A with the Cast: After the matinee on Saturday, April 28, stick around for a lively Q&A with cast members directly following the performance.


PAPER MILL PLAYHOUSE, a not-for-profit arts organization under the direction of Mark S. Hoebee (Producing Artistic Director) and Todd Schmidt (Managing Director) and recipient of the 2016 Regional Theatre Tony Award, is one of the country’s leading regional theaters.  Paper Mill Playhouse programs are made possible, in part, by funds from the New Jersey State Council on the Arts, a partner agency of the National Endowment for the Arts.Paper Mill Playhouse is a member of the National Alliance for Musical Theatre, the Council of Stock Theatres, and the New Jersey Theatre Alliance.

For additional information, please visit